Walk-In Showers vs. Bathtubs: Which Is Best for Your Space?

A Practical Guide for Homeowners in Barrie and Surrounding Areas

When it comes to bathroom renovations, one of the most common questions we hear at Ace Contracting is: “Should I go with a walk-in shower or keep the bathtub?” The answer depends on several factors—your lifestyle, available space, future plans, and even the real estate market in Barrie.

If you're considering a bathroom remodel and wondering which option is best for your home, this guide will help you weigh the pros and cons of both.

Walk-In Showers: Modern, Accessible, and Space-Saving

Walk-in showers are growing in popularity across Barrie homes, especially in modern and smaller bathrooms. They're ideal for homeowners looking for a sleek, open design and improved accessibility.

Advantages of Walk-In Showers:

• Space Efficiency: Great for small bathrooms where every square foot counts.

• Easy to Clean: Fewer corners and crevices make walk-in showers easier to maintain.

• Accessibility: A barrier-free design is safer for seniors or people with mobility issues.

• Modern Aesthetics: Frameless glass and clean tile lines give a contemporary look.

• Custom Options: You can add niches, benches, rain heads, and more to suit your needs.

Considerations:

• Resale Value: Some buyers—especially families—prefer at least one tub in the home.

• Waterproofing: Proper waterproofing and drainage are essential, especially in older Barrie homes with dated plumbing.

• Cost: Custom walk-in showers can be more expensive due to tiling and custom glass.

Bathtubs: Versatile, Family-Friendly, and Resale-Oriented

Bathtubs are a classic feature in many homes, and for good reason. They’re not just functional—they also offer comfort and relaxation.

Advantages of Bathtubs:

• Ideal for Families: Households with young children often find a tub essential for bath time.

• Resale Appeal: Many real estate agents in Barrie recommend having at least one tub in the home.

• Relaxation: Soaker or jetted tubs provide a spa-like experience.

• Cost: Basic tub installations can be more affordable than custom showers.

Considerations:

• Takes Up More Space: Not ideal for smaller bathrooms.

• Accessibility: Stepping into a tub can be difficult for older adults or those with mobility issues.

• Cleaning: More grout lines and fixtures may require extra upkeep.

So, Which Is Best for Your Bathroom?

Here’s how to decide:

1. How Much Space Do You Have?

Smaller bathrooms may benefit from a walk-in shower, while larger bathrooms can often accommodate both.

2. Who Uses the Bathroom?

If children or elderly family members use the space, a tub may be more practical. For ensuite master bathrooms, a walk-in shower may be the preferred choice.

3. Are You Renovating to Sell?

In Barrie's competitive real estate market, having at least one tub in the home is often recommended for resale value.

4. What’s Your Budget?

While standard bathtubs can be cost-effective, custom showers offer more long-term value and design flexibility—if your budget allows.

Ace Contracting Can Help You Decide

Whether you're upgrading an outdated tub or redesigning your entire bathroom, Ace Contracting can help you make the right choice for your home, your lifestyle, and your budget.

We specialize in bathroom renovations across Barrie, Innisfil, Orillia, Angus, and other nearby areas, offering full-service remodeling from design to final inspection.

Ready to plan your dream bathroom? Contact Ace Contracting for a free consultation today.